Sunday, May 9, 2010

Oh God, Even Confucius writes Sexist Books. Analects 15, 17, 18

The very first thing worth mentioning of these books is that they touch many topics in a few paragraphs. I think it was a great way of blending theses numerous topics in the teacher-student relationship. As humans we are very curious, we tend to ask many questions and want answers, if we didn’t we wouldn’t be exploring space or the depths of the ocean or know all the things we do about them. So if you are someone’s disciple, you learn from your Master, and what better way of learning that to ask things.

I experienced a hard-core question and answer discussion between the Master and one of his disciples. One that I thought was really interesting but at the same time I thought touched many topics that didn’t relate with each other. To make the discussion short, some of the topics were: how gentlemen and common men relate towards hard ship, running a state, what true mistakes are, to judge on your own accord not on everyone else’s decision and how to treat a music master. Though I know the Master doesn’t claim to know everything, he seems pretty knowledgeable to me, but then again, he is the Master after all. Personally I liked a lot the master answers to these questions. He was direct and made his point clear.

Something I had noticed a long time ago but hadn’t really mentioned was how important music seems to be for them. Some of them even play instruments. The Master talks about good music that helps and music that makes people unruly. I think that music today is still a great thing in people’s lives, it even puts people in categories, like if you listen to different types of music you’re a classified as a Goth or as a Punk. Also there is a reference towards happy people who listen to music, how people who are mourning don’t listen to music. That however is different to now days because you can find anything you want to listen to even if you are depressed.

Another thing I think is worth mentioning is that in many books that are meant to be read and followed, the ones with teachings, are always giving meaning to (or at least mentioning) strong humans emotions such as death and mourning. I think this is because it is one of the most confusing things we know, we don’t know what causes us to feel or act in certain way that we do and we try to look for answers in places where maybe there are none.

Now, I found something I wasn’t to happy about but I wasn’t surprised it was there either. I had been asking myself all this time why Confucius said that someone who was Good was a gentleman, what about Good women? They couldn’t certainly be called gentlemen as well could they? But then I stumbled upon this sentence:

17.25 The Master said, “Women and servants are particularly hard to manage: if you are too familiar with them, they grow insolent, but if you are too distant, they grow resentful.”

I dont really appreciate the comment but ive heard worst. But im a little confused, do they mean that women can never take the path of Goodness? The Way? Actually, ive never seem a place where they say that women can lead the path that is suposeldy the correct one in other great “teaching” books. It dosent sya they can´t, but its something you seem to notice once you read them entirely and ther is not one women mentioned that wasent just used to beggt someone, and sometimes not even that.

The final book, book 18, I think surprised me a little, because so far it was the most story-like book yet, I wonder if the Analects of Confucius are open to different types of narration, I guess they are.

No comments:

Post a Comment